Menu
Honoring the Legends of Blue Mountain Baseball
The Blue Mountain League Baseball Hall of Fame serves as a sacred repository for the storied history of our league's standout players.
We are dedicated to preserving the legacies of players, coaches, and contributors whose excellence has defined baseball in the Blue Mountain region for generations.
This digital shrine honors their grit, celebrates their achievements, and ensures that the spirit of our greatest legends continues to inspire the community and beyond.
Members of the Blue Mountain League Hall of Fame
Class of 1984 (Charter Members)
Neil Catalino
Joe DeFrank
Edgar Dietz
Earl Dreisbach
Karl Dutt
Bill Goldsworth
Gene Hartzell
Paul Keglovitz
Paul Kocher Sr.
Dave Lutz
Al Nerino
Hal Nerino
Jim Oplinger
O.R. Pacchioli
Paul Peters
Mike Pontrelli
Dick Pritchard
Len Renaldo
Amelio Scott
Bob Siebler
Domicic Spagnola
Val Valetta
Bob Weiss
Armon Williams
Class of 1985
Craig Anderson
Tony Cortez
Joe DeFrancisco
Sid Effross
George Enstrom
Lou Guida
Chet Huber
Joe Kluska
Floyd Kresge
Tom Morgan
Randall Ott
Bill Pensyl Sr.
Bob Rasely
Charles Rotzell
Rich Santo
Jim Schlegal
Guy Segatti
Art Stasiak
Gary Strauss
Charles Tarsi
Bill Williams
Class of 1986
Ray Biondi
Woodrow Bonney
Joe Dell'Alba
Ed Dreisbach
Ralph Fisher
Gus Garscar
Howie Gutshall
Dave James
Steve Majczan
Lou Pacchioli
George Pitsilos
Horace Rusling
Vince Seaman
Al Spadt
John Vonelli
Class of 1989
Terry Bartolet
Tom Kostolsky
Steve Michael
Dan Santiago
Gene Sostorecz
Mike Zuk
Class of 1988
Ciff Cowlings
Al Jones
Paul Kocher Jr.
Mel Kohler
Jim Lees
Ted Plessl
Bert Tarboro Jr.
Larry Valetta
Mike Zaia
Class of 1987
Richard DeLong
Ernie DiSalvatore
John Enstom
Ishky Fatzinger
Dick Holly
George Horwath
Pully Lasko
Jim Lugg
Paul Pavelko
Class of 1992
Rick Cacciatore
Dave Cardell
Mike Deschler
Frank John
Ted Long
Class of 1991
Larry Enstrom
Keith Groller
Jerry Wartman
Rich Wescoe
Class of 1995
Hal Ambrose
Phil Bollman
Greg Butz
Bill Filipovits
Bill Zanette
Frank Zellner
Class of 1990
Earl Brittain
Jack Hafer
Gary Jerabek
Marty Ondrovic
Pete Radocha
Paul Zellner
Class of 1994
Gary Albright
Brennan Arndt
Gus Kovalsky
Tony Liberto
Henry Oncheck
Bill Sakovics
Randy Seltzer
Class of 1998
Mickey Corpora
Carl Duser
George Harris
Carl Pietrouchie
Bill Polaha
Bob Thomas
Class of 1993
Jay Johnson
Howard Lawler
Bob Schuster
Dan Waelchli
Class of 1997
Ray Dech
Dave Hemmerly
Bob Hilinski
Frank Jurasits
Lou Minotti
Mike Miorelli
Class of 2001
Dick James
Mike Schneider
Gus Steiner
Mike Stockley
Jim Trach
Class of 1996
Tom Lasko
Bill Lipsky
Andy Onkotz
Bill Sawyer
Stan Sterner
Greg Vogel
Class of 2000
Andy Donatelli
Jim Kilpatrick
Dave Norwood
Dan Olshefski
Mike Quigley
Class of 2004
Eric Charles
Andy Cichocki
Tom Cichocki
Chris Mihalik
Drew Wesnak
Class of 1999
George Cobb
Dennis Kinney
Frank Marakovits
Mike Mihalik
Bill Pensyl
Class of 2003
Mike Collier
Jeff Kilpatrick
John King
Jim Martin
Dave Riegel
Class of 2007
Scott Brosky
John Csencsits
Matt Merkle
Sharon Miller
Bob Siemon
Joe Yanek
Class of 2002
John Bisco
Lee Butz
Tim Fisher
Troy Heffelfinger
Gene Jani
Bob Zerfass
Class of 2006
Bill Bosak
Ed Boyce
Mike Guro
Ted Meixell
Mike Saccani
Class of 2010
Jeff Bosak
Tom Byrd
Sean Leary
Tim Schwarz
Class of 2005
Dave Boandl
John Cole
Ted Damiter
Bill Flyte
Tom Stoudt
Class of 2009
Matt Hlay
Jim Schaffer
Fred Tomasko
Ed Wandler
Mike Wandler
Class of 2013
Andy Pitsilos
Nate Stannard
Scott Thomas
Class of 2008
Stan Dyrek
Rich Fenstermaker
Joe Ragazino
Karl Rentzheimer
Terry Sandercock
Class of 2012
Ted Delong
Lester Dietz
Scot Engler
Mike Reenock
Eric Reiter
Class of 2016
Tim Buck
Cal Kresge
Mike Pavolko
Chris Rios
Class of 2011
Tom George
Jeff Merlet
Ron "Punkin" Miller
Andy Simmock
Class of 2019
Jay Rothenhausler
Adam Sandt
Class of 2015
Mike Deutsch
Mike Palos
Tom Stoudt, Jr.
Class of 2014
Mike Bodnar
Ross Griffith
Tony Jordan
Chad Kusko
Gary Laubach
P.J. Yoder
Class of 2022
Jesse Borden
Jeff LaPorta
Class of 2018
Rocky Gencarelli
Chris Grynaviski
Jack Kinney
Class of 2025
Brian Cope
Andy Robison
CJ Saveri
Class of 2017
Ryan Driscoll
Nate King
Tim Moran
Class of 2021
Brandon Leslie
Mark Nicholas
Class of 2020
Chris Sule
Mark Washburn
Class of 2024
Nick Bowen
Erick Kresge
David Stoudt
Class of 2023
Matt Edwards
Brandon Nardella
Rick Seltzer
Nomination Process
Honoring excellence requires a rigorous and transparent evaluation. Follow our structured four-step methodology and selection process for the Blue Mountain League Hall of Fame.
Participation
Length of Career
Nomination
Active Participants
Candidates must have demonstrated a high level of performance, leadership, and integrity as a player, coach, manager, umpire, league official or team official.
Candidates shall have participated in the Blue Mountain League in some manner for a period of not less than five (5) years.
Candidates may be selected for their contribution in one category even though they are still active in the League in another category. Players, to be selected, must be inactive as a player for at least five (5) years.
Coaches, managers, league officials, umpires, and team officials may be selected while still active in the BML, provided they have participated in the League for at least ten (10) years.